AI outperforms Dubai doctor in X-ray analysis, sparks debate on threat to medical professions

A Dubai-based pulmonologist was recently taken aback when an artificial intelligence (AI) diagnostic tool outperformed him in identifying pneumonia on a chest X-ray. Dr Mohammad Fawzi Katranji, with 20 years of medical experience, conducted a side-by-side comparison, marking areas he believed indicated infection. The AI system not only validated his assessment but also detected an additional area he had missed.

Also read: AI in healthcare: Inclusive vision for Karnataka at LHIF 2025

The incident underscores the growing capabilities of AI in healthcare diagnostics. While Katranji initially approached the demonstration with confidence, the AI’s swift and accurate analysis left him visibly unsettled. The moment highlighted the widening gap between human expertise and machine precision in diagnostic radiology.

Some experts expressed concern over job security in the medical field, echoing the doctor's apprehension. Others, however, viewed the development as a valuable advancement, suggesting that AI tools could enhance rather than replace human roles in medicine.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Dr. Mohmmad Fawzi Katranji (@drfawzikatranji)

AI-powered platforms like Lunit INSIGHT CXR are now capable of scanning and interpreting medical images within seconds, offering diagnostic precision that rivals seasoned physicians. The episode illustrates not just the speed of technological progress, but also the broader implications for healthcare professionals navigating an increasingly automated future.

This aligns with broader predictions about AI’s disruptive potential, including those by tech leaders who foresee a redefinition of traditional roles in medicine and beyond.